SGP
Home Teach the Skills About SGP

Behavior List

Defiance & Power Struggles: Arguing



What's Happening:

Arguing often comes from a need to feel heard, respected, or in control. Children may argue when they feel misunderstood, overwhelmed, or when expectations feel unfair or unclear.
THIS

Option A: Gentle / Connection-Based Response
Use this when emotions are driving the argument.
How to do it:
Stay calm and neutral
Acknowledge the point beneath the words

What to say:
"You have strong feelings about this."
"I hear what you're saying."

Why it works: Feeling heard reduces the need to keep pushing.

Option B: Trauma-Informed / Nervous System Support
Use this when arguing escalates quickly.
How to do it:
Pause the interaction
Reduce language

What to say:
"Let's take a break."
"We'll talk when we're calm."

Why it works: Pausing prevents escalation and supports regulation.

Option C: Calm Boundary + Skill-Building
Use this when arguing becomes a pattern.
How to do it:
Set a clear limit
Redirect to respectful communication

What to say:
"I'm open to talking, not arguing."
"Use respectful words."

Why it works: Boundaries teach healthy communication.
NOT THAT

Engaging in power struggles
Raising your voice
Trying to "win" the argument

Teach the Skill

Practice expressing disagreement respectfully.

Learn how to teach the skills.



Back

SteadyGroundParenting.com


This guide is for educational purposes only and is not intended to replace professional medical, psychological, or mental health care. Adapt strategies to meet individual needs.
Privacy Policy